**I am shocked <- moderator deleted my topic instead of deleting the bad posts**

Site Feedback
#1

@ROSEHAN @Roseken @ROSELOA @Roseinoz

A moderator deleted my topic "Are we complaining too harshly about HiFi Rose products”. They should have deleted the bad posts not my topic.

This topic positively supported HiFi Rose, their customer support & their products.

I’ve sent a message to the above moderators and no response.

This topic received over 18 likes. I don’t understand. I asked why & no reply. Its as if I’m being penalized for other people’s bad posts.

I really feel insulted to the point of deleting all my topics, then deleting my community account and permanently leave this community forum.

I hope they can reply to help me understand and hopefully restore the topic without the bad posts.

6 Likes
#2

GREAT… Rose finally did the right thing.

PS:
@joyofmvid, buy a 130 first so you can have a say, and then you can make demands.

Have fun in other forums, but you won’t get far there either.

Thanks, Rose :clap:t2: :clap:t2: :clap:t2: :kissing_heart:

3 Likes
#3

I am shocked as well after you have contributed so many useful tips and guidelines for hifi rose products to this forum. I feel sorry for you @joyofmvid

Thought about to say something before this post is deleted. But after a second thought, why bother ?

What a hifi rose team !

2 Likes
#4

Remember that this is their website, not yours

2 Likes
#5

I agree TomT, thanks for your contributions joyofmvid. Don’t let that one thread derail your participation here, I’m sure many users have benefited from it.

1 Like
#6

I totally understand being frustrated — having your post deleted can feel dismissive, especially when you’re trying to engage in good faith.
But the speed of the escalation here is… something.
He went from being a vocal advocate asking “Are we complaining too harshly about HiFi Rose products?”
— to now feeling so insulted he’s ready to wipe his posts, delete his account, and walk away entirely.
The irony of the original post getting removed only adds fuel to the fire.
Just sayin’…

#7

Frankly, I don’t get it either.

It’s like you want to belong to a book club, you turn up at the meetings, you offer very detailed suggestions about how the book should have been written and edited but - remarkably - you haven’t even bought the book, nor read it at all…

Sounds like a lot of free time to spare.

4 Likes
#8

Well the moderation here appears to need improvement . Hopefully they catch on and are able to make the right calls

#9

Everyone is eagerly waiting for your ban. You have seriously annoyed everyone here. You are the instigator of scandals and constantly throw pseudo-audiophile crap at the fan. Besides apparently being a very unhappy person, you are also very stupid. Perhaps you are yet another victim of Jeffrey Epstein’s abuse :heart:, but what does that have to do with the members of this forum? You need to see a psychiatrist.

3 Likes
#10

Hello Vik :v:t2:

I totally agree.

It’s time for Rose to do something!!!

Tricycle! Go back where you came from!

1 Like
#11

Frankly, I don’t think the staff really care. If they do, they should have stepped forward long long time ago.

3 Likes
#12

Who’s everyone, you and Boris and two others elite audiophiles? I am trying to make peace here, please don’t make personal attacks. It was Bonte and his little buddy Boris peddling his banana peel nonsense and SPAMing every forum trying to make believe his vintage , bargain basement equipment was better than everyone else. I was just offering an alternate viewpoint that believes those older, cheaper equipment are not good compared to ROSE flagship products and other higher price points from better brands . Some of us just are way past old, used speakers and beginner equipment , we’re not allowed to do that in peace ?

#13

Please Bonte, I’m just responding to Boris, has nothing to do with you or your boyfriend Boris. Again, I am politely asking you to leave me alone and not mention me. I have no interest in interacting with you.

#15

Also, I would agree with the others. You’ve been a great influence around here. Stay positive and keep up your good work. Don’t let this get you down.

#16

I just noticed the “Guidelines for Positive Participation in HiFi Rose Community” was re-pinned globally yesterday, even though it has been sitting in the forum for 3 years. https://community.roseaudio.kr/t/guidelines-for-positive-participation-in-hifi-rose-community/4832

According to those Guidelines:

Blockquote
Respectful language: We recommend that you use respectful language and avoid any form of hate speech, harassment, or personal attacks towards others.

Blockquote
Constructive criticism: We encourage you to share your experiences with HIFI ROSE products, but please ensure that any feedback or criticism is constructive and not intended to harm or insult other users.

Blockquote
No trolling or inciting drama: We recommend that you do not engage in trolling or intentionally incite drama or conflict within the community.

Blockquote
Moderation: If you notice any behavior that violates these recommendations, please report it to the moderators, who will take appropriate action to address the situation.

By no means to make matters worse, but while most of us value the respectful exchange of HiFi and audiophile ideas in this forum, there are some individuals who are repeatedly harassing and attacking others with foul language to suppress differing viewpoints.

Multiple members, including myself, have reported these instances to the moderation team many times – both directly and indirectly via different posts – as these behaviors not only violate the HiFi Rose Community Guidelines regarding “Respectful language” and “No trolling,” but have also created a hostile atmosphere that discourages proper productive dialogue.

Sadly, it is disappointing that we have seen neither an appropriate reply nor any proper intervention taken by the moderation team against these individuals to resolve these conflicts in a timely manner according to the Community Guidelines. Worse still, some members, such as @joyofmvid, appear to have been unfairly penalized for the disruptive behavior of others (see this post).

While I don’t hold out much hope, I once more urge the moderation team, @ROSEHAN and @ROSELOA, to intervene fairly and justly from now on to ensure this forum remains “a positive and respectful environment for all users”, which HiFi Rose and the moderation team committed to in the official Guidelines.

1 Like
#17

This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.

1 Like
#18

@Bicycle

Finally, I will issue a warning to @BorisM
If this issue occurs again, we will consider taking action, including a ban.

4 Likes
#19

Thank you Rosehan. I am a very dedicated supporter of Hifi Rose, and will ensure commitment to a respectful and safe community . I am willing to be banned permanently with Boris if it means keeping our community safe from future violations.

#20

Hello Eun-Seong Han,

I really appreciate you as a moderator! You always give quick and constructive answers. I read everything in this forum.

What I don’t understand is why only @BorisM is being punished!

Since the bike reappeared here, the whole madness has really taken off.

I ask you to see both sides of the coin and to reconsider your decision!

Kind regards, Bonte…:v:t2:

1 Like
#21

Bonte, @Bonte @BorisM

As I mentioned several times, this is about enforcing the rules. Whether it’s me or Boris, nobody has a right to call another person “idiot”, “dumb” or any other harassing word . I have committed to following all of those rules now, and Boris must do the same or he will be banned . If I don’t follow the rules, I ask that I be banned too. The rules will be applied equally to all.

2 Likes